Reborns Logo
                   
Sign In
   


     Kelli J. Newcome
Garden of Eden Nursery
WV, United States

    5.0


Seller Reviews (91)

    170 orders sold
1 order bought
2 years on Reborns
299 followers
169 Items Listed

Facebook   Instagram   

Visit Shop   Contact
Reviews I've Left Buyers (78)     


Meig Maycumber wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Feb 5, 2023
Stunning creativity, the pacifier pal is perfect and one of the most beautiful crocheted items I have ever had the pleasure to own!
Pacifier Pal Your Choice

Ordered:
Jan 30, 2023

Shaylee barney wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
The packaging was so beautiful and fun to open! It felt like Christmas! She goes above and beyond! And the quality is top notch! I’ll definitely be back for more! ❤️
Little Wizard Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 27, 2023

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
I am a repeat customer, never disappointed
Purple Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 22, 2023

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
I am a big fan of Kelli’s work, great seller
Pacifier Pal Your Choice

Ordered:
Jan 23, 2023

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
Just one more example of Kelli’s fine work, I am addicted !!!!!
Sunflower Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 30, 2023

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
This sweet little bunny outfit is the most darling, Kelli is a wonderful sellet.
Bunny Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 30, 2023

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Feb 4, 2023
I have purchased several of Kelli’s baby outfits. They just get cuter all the time, shipped fast and nicely wrapped.
Pink Tulip Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 30, 2023

Karen Roe wrote:       (has left 4 seller reviews) Jan 23, 2023
Kelli created a beautiful baby and made a darling little sweater set for her. The box opening was lovely. Kelli answered every question & shipping was fast. Thank you for my darling girl.
Estella

Ordered:
Jan 14, 2023

Amy Lanza wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Jan 10, 2023
Love this so much! It looks so cute on my baby!
Purple Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Dec 27, 2022

Susan Dunn wrote:       (has left 12 seller reviews) Dec 29, 2022
Very good quality, matched picture, good communicator, quick shipper.
Willow

Ordered:
Dec 19, 2022

Meghan McIntosh wrote:       (has left 8 seller reviews) Dec 28, 2022
A Christmas gift for my mom & she loves it!! The glow worm is super cute! Love the colors! So bright & cheerful!
Neon Outfit

Ordered:
Sep 29, 2022

Lacy West wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Dec 27, 2022
My favorite outfit!!! The best. Thanks so much!
Honey Bear Outfit

Ordered:
Nov 19, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Dec 22, 2022
Kelly's crocheted creations are always amazing!!
Unicorn Hooded Jacket

Ordered:
Oct 1, 2022

Melissa McCloskey wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Dec 7, 2022
OMG! The little polar bear outfit I received from Kelli is amazing! Awesome craftsmanship and speedy delivery! I will order from her again!
Polar Bear Outfit

Ordered:
Dec 3, 2022

Elizabeth J Grinavic wrote:       (has left 13 seller reviews) Dec 6, 2022
Still cannot emphasize enough how much I love Kelli's work! Thanks again! :)
Gingerbeard Outfit

Ordered:
Nov 23, 2022

Joshua Cirone wrote:       (has left 13 seller reviews) Dec 6, 2022
Excellent sale. Very fast shipping. Beautiful baby. I will be a return customer.
Elfling Destiny

Ordered:
Dec 3, 2022

Renanda Merritt wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Dec 2, 2022
Tala is so cute! Her coloring is perfect! This little girl is a treasured part of my collection!
Tala

Ordered:
Nov 25, 2022

Renanda Merritt wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Nov 22, 2022
Kelli's craftsmanship is AWESOME!!! The quality is superb! I will be buying again from Kelli!
Crocheted Spring Outfit

Ordered:
Apr 21, 2022

KC Texan wrote:       (has left 48 seller reviews) Nov 3, 2022
I love this little red head. She looks so different from the other Sydneys I've seen. Her eyes look so alive and attentive. Thank you!
Sydney

Ordered:
Oct 28, 2022

Kristen M Brock wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Nov 3, 2022
Another absolutely adorable set of ghost paci-pals from Kelli! ❤️ If you’re looking for cute accessories for your babies, be sure to order from Kelli…high quality cuteness that deserves 10 stars! ⭐️
Pacifier Pals

Ordered:
Oct 17, 2022

Tamera Petzoldt wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Oct 29, 2022
What a precious little girl from a wonderful seller! 🥰♥️💖
Maddie

Ordered:
Sep 25, 2022

Marlese Hine wrote:       (has left 79 seller reviews) Oct 21, 2022
Thank you Kelli ! You did a wonderful job creating these adorable bears 😊 Excellent communication too !
Pacifier Pal Your Choice

Ordered:
Oct 18, 2022

Kimberly Ann wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Oct 20, 2022
Kelli was an absolute pleasure to work with! She is so talented! I love the little frog and ghost. They are perfect! I’ll definitely be ordering from her again! Thank you so much!
Frog & Ghost Custom Order

Ordered:
Oct 17, 2022

Elizabeth J Grinavic wrote:       (has left 13 seller reviews) Oct 17, 2022
Very well done outfit, it's adorable! Definitely recommend Kelli!
Frog Outfit

Ordered:
Oct 13, 2022

Tracy Evans wrote:       (has left 1 seller review) Oct 15, 2022
She is absolutely amazing!! So much better than I expected!
Laura

Ordered:
Oct 11, 2022

Kristen M Brock wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Sep 30, 2022
❤️ Kelli creates the cutest pacifier pals! I love my first order of ghost paci pals, and had to add the adorable little pig to my collection too! Each critter is exactly as described and so cute! ❤️
Ghost Paci Pal-You Pick

Ordered:
Sep 23, 2022

Christy Culverhouse wrote:       (has left 3 seller reviews) Sep 26, 2022
Beautiful creation!! Fast shipping will buy from again!
Pacifier Pal

Ordered:
Sep 9, 2022

Sara Olson wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Sep 23, 2022
So adorable! I love the ears😊
3pc Crocheted Set

Ordered:
Sep 19, 2022

Kristen M Brock wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Sep 23, 2022
Kelli has been a joy to work with, and her paci pals are absolutely adorable! If you’re looking for cute photo props for your reborn babies, I highly recommend shopping at Garden of Eden Nursery! ❤️
Ghost Pacifier Pals

Ordered:
Sep 20, 2022

Judy santulli wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Sep 16, 2022
She does beautiful work highly recommend her
Hooded Jacket 0/3m

Ordered:
Sep 13, 2022

Vera Swensen wrote:       (has left 1 seller review) Sep 11, 2022
I got the doll earlier than expected she came on Friday instead on Saturday which was a good thing because my daughter had to work on Saturday and she loved it how it came a day early
Hudson

Ordered:
Sep 5, 2022

Ashley Hart wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Sep 11, 2022
Absolutely love the outfit 😍😍😍
Honey Bear Outfit

Ordered:
Sep 3, 2022

Kim carr wrote:       (has left 1 seller review) Sep 10, 2022
Little Thomas is a tiny little sweetheart! he is just adorable with those big eyes! An his soft beautifully rooted red hair! Kelli is very easy and accommodating to work with! She answers promptly!
Thomas

Ordered:
May 12, 2022

Laura A. Young wrote:       (has left 36 seller reviews) Sep 7, 2022
I have purchased from Kelli before and I am very happy with her. It is always a pleasure adopting babies from nursery! Thank you for Erin, she is a little blessing to me! God Bless, Laura
Erin

Ordered:
Aug 29, 2022

Sara Olson wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Aug 22, 2022
I absolutely love this!! Thank you💜
Pink/Gray/Green Outfit

Ordered:
Aug 17, 2022

Tamera Petzoldt wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Aug 17, 2022
Absolutely beautiful! And what a sweet seller!🥰
Peaches

Ordered:
Aug 11, 2022

Laura A. Young wrote:       (has left 36 seller reviews) Aug 7, 2022
I was very pleased with baby Tessa! Kelli was very helpful, and followed up after I received Tessa. I would recommend purchasing a reborn from Kelli any time! Laura Young
Tessa

Ordered:
Jul 11, 2022

Karey Shipley wrote:       (has left 11 seller reviews) Jul 30, 2022
-Absolutely amazing work!! I love your creations!! Thank you!! You are so very talented!! ♥️
Hunny Bear Outfit

Ordered:
Jul 23, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Jul 25, 2022
I just put this outfit on my little guy and it is so beautiful! Great job again Kelli 💖💖 the material feels so great and looks wonderful!
Honey Loving Teddy Outfit

Ordered:
Jul 15, 2022

Jacqueline Ann Siggers wrote:       (has left 23 seller reviews) Jul 15, 2022
The second baby purchased from Kelli. Always a smooth transaction and great communication.
Aria

Ordered:
May 18, 2022

Krista Kulow wrote:       (has left 8 seller reviews) Jul 13, 2022
She is smaller than I thought but when I dress her or hold her she puts a smile on my face. Thank you
Tala Elfling

Ordered:
Jun 21, 2022

Krista Kulow wrote:       (has left 8 seller reviews) Jul 13, 2022
I was looking for an elf and so excited to get her. She is beautiful and I am so happy to have her.
Elf Fee

Ordered:
Jun 1, 2022

Karey Shipley wrote:       (has left 11 seller reviews) Jul 11, 2022
-Absolutely incredible work!! I can not recommend Kelli enough as a seller!! I just sat and held Quinn for hours! Every detail and his sweet little face was perfect!! Thank you so much!! 🧡
Quinn

Ordered:
Jul 3, 2022

Karey Shipley wrote:       (has left 11 seller reviews) Jul 11, 2022
-This outfit is perfect!! Great craftsmanship!! Very unique and I love one of a kind pieces!! Communication with Kelli was great!! Fast shipping and packaged very well!! Thank you!! Highly recommend!!
Pink/Green Outfit

Ordered:
Jul 3, 2022

Dara Gowan wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Jun 10, 2022
My sweet Peaches is the perfect squeezable baby. You just want to hug and hold her all day! And I’m absolutely certain I’ll be a returning customer for another beautiful creation!
Peaches

Ordered:
Jun 4, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) May 23, 2022
This outfit is gorgeous! I put it on a baby as soon as it arrived and don't want to take it off!!! Her crochet is art!
Colorful Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
May 13, 2022

Elizabeth J Grinavic wrote:       (has left 13 seller reviews) May 4, 2022
I love it, it's beautiful, thank you!
Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Apr 29, 2022

Shaylee barney wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Apr 28, 2022
I ordered Pearl and Skya and they are absolutely perfect! Kelli is a dream to work with, such a sweet person. This has been such an amazing experience and they arrived very quickly. Thank you So much!
Peral

Ordered:
Apr 23, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Apr 20, 2022
Beautiful outfit and the colors of pink and white are so inviting! Love this ensemble so much for my babies💖
Crocheted TeddyBear Set

Ordered:
Apr 7, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Apr 20, 2022
I love the colors and you did a great job creating this piece 😍
Crocheted Outfit Newborn

Ordered:
Apr 7, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Apr 20, 2022
This outfit is amazing! Thank you Kelli!
Rag Doll Outfit

Ordered:
Apr 7, 2022

Sherry Welsh wrote:       (has left 26 seller reviews) Apr 16, 2022
Beautiful crochet, and a great seller, Thank You
Your Choice-Pacifier Pals

Ordered:
Apr 6, 2022

Renanda Merritt wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Apr 11, 2022
Kelli, I love this little guy! His skin color is perfect! Clyde is a welcome addition to my nursery!
Clyde

Ordered:
Apr 7, 2022

Shelley M Lohr wrote:       (has left 20 seller reviews) Apr 7, 2022
Beautiful Outfit!!! Quick Shipping & Nice Packaging.
Crocheted Outfit-Cow

Ordered:
Apr 4, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Apr 2, 2022
Kelli is a true artist at crochet! This little ensemble is baby soft and beautiful!
Crocheted Bear Set

Ordered:
Feb 24, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Apr 2, 2022
Absolutely gorgeous and cloud soft. High quality materials and great workmanship.
Crocheted Duck Outfit

Ordered:
Feb 24, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Apr 2, 2022
Kelli has made so many babies for me, but they are always perfect. This little guy is so precious. She is always so wonderful to work with. Kelli is a blessing to her customers.
Samuel

Ordered:
Mar 24, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Mar 10, 2022
I love the design choices and colors! I highly recommend all of your crochet outfits!
Crocheted Rainbow Outfit

Ordered:
Mar 6, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Mar 10, 2022
Beautiful outfit as usual! I love your clothes. Thank you!
Peach Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Mar 6, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Feb 26, 2022
I love all of the extras that come with this outfit! It is so beautifully created and gorgeous!
Crocheted Pig Outfit

Ordered:
Feb 22, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Feb 26, 2022
This outfit is beautiful and wonderfully made! I love it and the pictures did not do it justice! Great purchase!
Crocheted 3pc Outfit

Ordered:
Feb 22, 2022

Sherri Nguyen wrote:       (has left 52 seller reviews) Feb 26, 2022
My turtle just arrived and is so well made and beautiful! Thank you Kelli!
Turtle Pacifier Pal

Ordered:
Feb 22, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 23, 2022
So fun and bright and so well-made! Love, love, love Kelli's crochet creations!
3 Piece Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 21, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 23, 2022
Gorgeous, amazing outfit. Handmade reborn pieces from Kelli do not disappoint!
Handmade Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Jan 23, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 23, 2022
Absolutely beautiful, homemade, lovingly crafted outfit. The details on those tiny sandals are so sweet!
Crocheted Dress Set

Ordered:
Feb 8, 2022

Kristen Keith wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Feb 21, 2022
Cora Mae is a fabulous reborn that has been painted so realistically. Her skin tone and blushing are just perfect. Her eyelashes and rooted hair are wonderful. I highly recommend Kelli as an artist.
Cora Mae

Ordered:
Feb 1, 2022

Lisa Longendyke wrote:       (has left 15 seller reviews) Feb 20, 2022
This outfit is so precious!! It is well made and just adorable!
Unicorn Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Feb 9, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 19, 2022
There were so many beautiful surprises in this box and Bettie is the cutest, gorgeous little baby girl I could imagine. Her hair and painting are amazing!!
Bettie

Ordered:
Jan 25, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 19, 2022
She is gorgeous! Her skin tone, her hair... everything about her is perfect! Kelli is and always will be my favorite artist.
Indigo

Ordered:
Jan 20, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 19, 2022
One of the most beautiful cuddle babies I've adopted. Kelli NEVER disappoints!!
Andi

Ordered:
Jan 27, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Feb 19, 2022
Kelli is my favorite artist for a reason. This precious girl is so lifelike she takes my breath away. I'm new to this type of reborn and Kelli gave me great details and advice on Oakley. A+
Oakley

Ordered:
Feb 1, 2022

Lisa Walp wrote:       (has left 62 seller reviews) Feb 16, 2022
I just received this beautiful outfit that Kelli made. She is so talented and my little reborn looks so sweet in it. Thanks Kelli. I highly recommend her!!!
3pc Crocheted Outfit

Ordered:
Feb 10, 2022

Ana Gagnon wrote:       (has left 10 seller reviews) Feb 13, 2022
My beautiful handsome adorable baby boy I am so lucky to have him thank you for creating this baby boy for me you do wonderful job.
Tink

Ordered:
Feb 5, 2022

Jennifer Cruce wrote:       (has left 7 seller reviews) Feb 8, 2022
Shes adorable thankyou
Skya

Ordered:
Feb 3, 2022

Tamera Petzoldt wrote:       (has left 35 seller reviews) Feb 2, 2022
Total cutie pie! Thanks for this cutie!
Timothy

Ordered:
Jul 9, 2021

Jolene Anderson wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Jan 14, 2022
If I could leave 10 stars, I would! I had so many questions since this was my first one and she was so wonderful with her responses and quick at that. Would most definitely purchase from again!
Logan

Ordered:
Jan 11, 2022

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Jan 3, 2022
I opened this baby's blanket and cried. She is beyond anything I could imagine. The pictures don't come close to how perfect and beautiful she is!!!
June

Ordered:
Dec 30, 2021

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Dec 28, 2021
Kelli is absolutely wonderful to work with. She is an artist I would adopt from again and again.
Ryan

Ordered:
Dec 20, 2021

Shaylee barney wrote:       (has left 9 seller reviews) Dec 27, 2021
Super nice, great communication! She made the box opening absolutely beautiful and very heartfelt! Got the baby of my dreams and the whole experience made everything just so perfect! Thank you so much
Grumpy Sage

Ordered:
Dec 22, 2021

Misty Youngberg wrote:       (has left 14 seller reviews) Dec 21, 2021
Item as described but honestly, so much cuter in person! Great transaction. Timely shipment and wonderful communication. Great box opening.
Ducklin

Ordered:
Dec 17, 2021

Ana Gagnon wrote:       (has left 10 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
He's my Angel baby love him so much . beautiful baby 😘
Michael

Ordered:
Jun 21, 2021

Ana Gagnon wrote:       (has left 10 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
She's my beautiful adorable little baby girl 🥰😍.
Ward

Ordered:
Jul 3, 2021

Ana Gagnon wrote:       (has left 10 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
A great person to buy beautiful reborn baby dolls Kelli does wonderful work and she care so much for her customer she's really a great person and I feel lucky to know her.Ana Gagnon.
Grant

Ordered:
Oct 11, 2021

Sara Naylor wrote:       (has left 1 seller review) Dec 16, 2021
I simply adore this precious baby. She is beautiful and everything I was looking for. Box opening was better than expected. I can’t thank you enough for this precious gift, I cried. ❤️
Madison

Ordered:
Nov 3, 2021

Nicole Deuso wrote:       (has left 1 seller review) Dec 16, 2021
I love everything about my baby. Excellent quality. I have purchased approximately 10 reborns and he is in the top 3.
Jaxson

Ordered:
Oct 16, 2021

Suzanne Swan wrote:       (has left 2 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
My new baby is more than I could have hoped for. I enjoyed working with this artist. She is very kind. I hope to be working with her again and would definitely recommend you check out her work. 💜
Ever

Ordered:
Dec 1, 2021

Robin Gonzalez wrote:       (has left 3 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
Kelli was great to work with and her work is awesome. We love our baby girl
Patience

Ordered:
Sep 24, 2021

Tracy Kidson wrote:       (has left 4 seller reviews) Dec 16, 2021
Absolutely love my little one. She’s absolutely beautiful and exactly what I expected. I had a wonderful experience with Garden of Eden Nursery💕
Leighton Rose

Ordered:
Aug 17, 2021

Jacqueline Ann Siggers wrote:       (has left 23 seller reviews) Dec 10, 2021
It was such a pleasure interacting with Kelli. This cute little boy stole my heart with those big brown eyes and turned-down mouth. The hair is amazingly rooted and of high quality.
Ollie

Ordered:
Nov 9, 2021

Susan Gilmour wrote:       (has left 10 seller reviews) Dec 5, 2021
My Patience is a beautifully reborned bub! This nursery is great to deal with and I would happily purchase from them again. Amazing reborning!
Patience

Ordered:
Aug 12, 2021

Amanda Carlson wrote:       (has left 38 seller reviews) Dec 4, 2021
I cannot give enough stars. Gorgeous baby, amazing and kind seller and such a thoughtful box opening. Every detail was perfect. I cannot recommend this nursery enough.
Jade

Ordered:
Nov 13, 2021